Call For A Free Consultation With Local Attorneys

Florida Supreme Court: Attorney-Client Privilege

The Florida Supreme Court is set to consider how far defendants in personal injury suits can pry into possible referral relationships between doctors and attorneys, a move that defense attorneys say is necessary to peel back inflated costs for medical care in these cases. They agreed to hear the appeal after Worley made a valid argument that there was a conflict regarding whether a plaintiff must provide the production of information protected by attorney-client privilege.

medical review panel.jpgThe state's highest court will hear oral arguments in a slip-and-fall case brought by Heather Worley, who tripped and fell in the parking lot of Central Florida YMCA and was allegedly referred to a doctor by her attorneys at Morgan & Morgan.

Heather Worley injured herself after falling in a YMCA parking lot. After she fell in the YMCA's parking lot, Worley twice went to the emergency room of Florida Hospital East Orlando. Following her retention of Morgan & Morgan, various doctors from Sea Spine, Underwood and Sanctuary treated her and the firm filed a negligence suit against YMCA on Worley's behalf, seeking to recover damages that include the costs of her treatment from those providers. According to court documents, the case began as a "relatively routine" trip-and-fall incident, but that Morgan & Morgan has "tenaciously opposed" all attempts by the YMCA to learn how Worley became a patient of the doctors who treated her. The YMCA had said it has reason to believe that there's a "cozy agreement" between Morgan & Morgan and the treating physicians due to the unusually high cost of Worley's medical bills. During her deposition, the YMCA asked Worley how she came to see the specialists and if she was referred to a doctor by her lawyers. Her counsel objected on grounds of attorney-client privilege. Counsel for the YMCA successfully had the Court order Worley to turn over any documents relating to a connection between her counsel at Morgan & Morgan PA and physicians at Sea Spine Orthopedic Institute, Underwood Surgery Center and Sanctuary Surgical & Anesthesia Center. Worley appealed the order. In May, Florida's Fifth District Court of Appeals refused to overturn the trial court's order because, in the court's opinion, the YMCA had adequately shown that such a relationship could exist. The appellate court also said that because Worley said that no other doctors, friends or family members referred her to the doctors who treated her, the court must ask Worley herself. Worley then appealed it to the Florida Supreme Court. Her argument was based on attorney-client privilege. She viewed the order requiring her to produce any information of a possible referral relationship between the doctors who treated her and her lawyers, as eroding the attorney-client privilege. In her petition to the state's high court to review the order, Worley argued that the appellate court's ruling conflicted with precedent set in another state appellate court, saying that 1992 ruling held that the question of whether a lawyer referred his client to a particular treating physician was protected by the attorney-client privilege. Worley added that the fact that a witness's testimony may be impeached by the confidential communications between a party and her attorney doesn't give the opposing party the right to have those communications disclosed, regardless of need or undue hardship.



No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information

Father And Son Team Working Together To Serve Our Clients

Our legal team consists of attorney Wm. Dennis Brannon and his son C. Paul Brannon. We work together as a father and son team to provide our clients with exceptional service and solutions in motor vehicle accident claims and other personal injury matters.

Contact Us Today
Email Us For A Response

We Handle Cases on a Contingency Fee Basis Tell Us About Your Case - Free Consultations

Bold labels are required.

Contact Information

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.


Privacy Policy

Fort Walton Beach
975 Mar Walt Drive
Fort Walton Beach, FL 32547

Phone: 850-659-2252
Fax: 850-864-4526
Fort Walton Beach Law Office Map

544 US Highway 90 East
Defuniak Springs, FL 32433

Phone: 850-659-2252
Fax: 850-864-4526
Map & Directions

Destin Office
4507 Furling Lane
Suite 214
Destin, FL 32541

Phone: 850-842-2573
Map & Directions