Brannon & Brannon - Fort Walton Beach personal injury attorney
Call For A Free Consultation With Local Attorneys

Accidents: Make Sure Your Lawyer Preserves The Evidence

Evidence-Article-201407221432.jpgInsurance giant GEICO is being scrutinized after an East St Louis trucking company recently filed a lawsuit against the firm. According to a report in the Madison-St Clair Record, Beelman Truck Company filed the complaint alleging that GEICO had breached its duty to retain and preserve a vehicle that was to be used as part of it’s defense in an underlying car accident lawsuit with claimant, Vera Rees.

According to the complaint, Bellman Truck Co. was named a defendant in three lawsuits after Vera Rees was in a collision, resulting in injuries and death to her passengers. The plaintiff (Beelman) asserts Geico negligently shipped the vehicle in question to Africa after it was prematurely sold, impeding Beelman’s ability to defend itself in court in the three lawsuits. Beelman alleges spoliation of evidence after Geico negligently allowed the vehicle to be sold. As a result, the plaintiff has requested a trial by jury and is seeking a judgment in an amount exceeding $50,000.

East St. Louis trucking company is suing Geico after the insurance company sold a vehicle that was evidence in three lawsuits.

Unlike in federal court, it is unclear in Florida state courts when the duty to preserve evidence starts. Presumably, under Florida law, there is no legal duty to preserve evidence until a discovery request is made. While there is no doubt that a party can be punished for failing to preserve evidence after it has a duty to do so, several Florida courts have sanctioned parties for failing to preserve evidence even when there was no such duty under Florida law. Faced with this ambiguity, your lawyer should send a letter requesting evidence be preserved once a lawsuit has been reasonably anticipated to occur and discuss with opposing parties the scope of preservation at the earliest opportunity.

 

http://www.floridabar.org/DIVCOM/JN/JNJournal01.nsf/8c9f13012b96736985256aa900624829/

e8c5bace669965a185257cc5005e90fc!OpenDocument

Categories

Archives

FindLaw Network
atto image

Father And Son Team Working Together To Serve Our Clients

Our legal team consists of attorney Wm. Dennis Brannon and his son C. Paul Brannon. We work together as a father and son team to provide our clients with exceptional service and solutions in motor vehicle accident claims and other personal injury matters.
Contact Us Today
atto image
AV Preeminent | Judical Edition
Judical Edition| AV Preeminent 2018| Wm. Dennis Brannon| Highest Possible Rating in Both Legal Ability and Ethical Standards Reflecting the confidential opinions of members of the Bar and Judiciary
Wm. Dennis Brannon | Highest Possible Peer Review Rating In Legal Ability & Ethical Standards
avvo

We Handle Cases on a Contingency Fee Basis
Tell Us About Your Case - Free Consultations